Givers VS Takers
How can you tell the difference between "Givers" and "Takers"? Here's a simple listing.
Givers | Takers |
Why shouldn't I help? | Why should I help? |
Don't question motivations | Ask "I wonder what they want?" |
Ask, "How will this benefit others?" | Ask, "What's in it for me?" |
Releasing | Controlling |
Finds power and peace in spiritual wisdom | Finds power and peace in externals and things |
Willing to be servants | Must be "lords" |
Follows the flow with insight | Appears "In control" |
Rolls with the punches | Easily overwhelmed |
Love unconditionally | "Love" conditionally |
High capacity for pain | Low capacity for pain |
Bear pain silently and with patience | Whiners |
Seldom call attention to themselves | Braggarts |
Live confidently, day by day | There's "always something..." to worry about |
May be left "holding the bag" | "Squeaky Clean" |
Pick up after themselves | Leave damage and behind in them |
Sharers | Collectors |
What can I do for them? | What's in it for me? |
Invest in people | Invest in selves |
Willing to give virtually unlimited resources | In need of virtually unlimited attention and support |
Dependable | Dependent |
No time table | Time, schedules closely monitored |
Flexible, open to sudden changes | "Too busy" |
No expectation of return | Tit-for-tat |
Simply give for the joy of it | Pre-occupied with facade of "gratitude" |
Help people change their own lives | Change people's lives for their own ends |
Committed to others | Committed to self |
Support | Undermine |
Energize | Drain energies |
Seek opportunities | Seek personal comfort |
Constructively critical | Judgmentally critical |
Do for themselves and others | Do for themselves only what others won't do for them |
Doesn't "use" others to a fault | Manipulative |
Releasing | Controlling |
Agenda is announced, overt, and open to scrutiny | Cleverly hidden agenda |
Trusting of leaders | Distrust any and all leaders |
Help unconditionally | Help given until angered |
Trusting, able to give the benefit of a doubt | Suspicious, untrusting |
Concerned with the essential and important | Perfectionistic and controlling |
Defensive/Supporting | Offensive/Attacking |
Can face and work through pain | Fear of pain and suffering |
Listeners | Needy talkers |
Flexible | Live by schedules |
Share comfort, confidence | Share discomfort, fear |
Gospel-Driven | Legalistic |
On spiritual pilgrimage | Resist spiritual transformation |
Worships God by giving life as a living sacrifice to God | Worships God according to their own set procedure, schedules, and manner |
Forgive, forget, and come back supportive | Don't forgive unless they have to |
Spontaneous, fun-loving | Rigid, rule-enforcer |
Willing to "break the rules" to show compassion | Live, fight and die by "principles" and "rights" |
Willingly give up their own agenda for others | Will stop at nothing to get their way |
Focus on becoming transformed for God's purposes | Focus on conforming others to themselves |
Concerned with the important | Concerned with the urgent |
Willing to pay the price for others' well-being | Make others pay the price for their desires, needs, wants |
Permeable boundaries | Impermeable, rigid boundaries |
Doers | Whiners |
Proactive | Reactive |
They come, assist, and when done, leave no "silver bullet" behind | "Humbly" seek "deserved" attention, affection, reward and recognition for efforts |
Willing to wash feet, take out trash, do dirty work | Refuse to submit to demeaning tasks below their dignity |
Focus on helping others achieve their goals | Focused on titles, position |
They can be ignored as long as people aren't hurt | Always must make a point and be heard no matter what the cost |
Help facilitate great healing | Cause much pain |
Patient | Impatient |
No shows | Overly polite, mannerly |
Help when others hurt | Cause helpers hurt |
Shed tears, feel deep grief when hurt | Don't talk, trust or feel |
Accept responsibility for their own behavior | Mercilessly project responsibility and blame on others |
Survivors | Victims |
Submit to God's will | God is Aladdin's Lamp |
Reality-based | Fantasy-driven "If only..." |
"Things" just aren't that important | Materialistic |
People are important | My things are important |
Internally driven by "grace" values | Externally driven |
Welfare-of-others conscious | Status conscious |
Expansive | Territorial |
Not appearance conscious (e.g. weight, height, clothes, figure, hair, coordination, flashiness) | Hyper-conscious and hyper-sensitive to appearance |
Attention tends to be deflected away | Draw attention to themselves by things (jewelry, cars, homes, et al) |
Do all they can to protect and uphold their neighbor's welfare | Pre-occupied with comparing others' wealth, benefits, possessions to their own |
Generous | Covetous |
Spenders | Savers |
Utilize all available resources | "Squirrel" things |
Maintain confidences, appropriate communication | Gossip, innuendo, behind the back conversations are characteristic |
No need for secrets | Keep secrets |
Give gifts freely | Gifts have strings attached |
Relationship unconditional | Relationship is conditional |
Want to reach out | Don't want to get involved |
Concerned | Aloof |
"I'll be there if you need me" | "See ya!" |
Willingly works even amid unfair treatment and conditions | Always expects "something for nothing" |
Will undergo humiliation and pain to assist others | Avoid embarrassment and risk for others |
Always growing | "Stuck" |
Encourages others growth | Restricts others growth |
Mistakes are the path to growth | Condemns, punishes mistakes |
Don't need to be asked | Appreciate being asked and needed |
Takes care of self and others | "Take care of me" |
Sensitive and genuinely empathetic to other's pain | Insensitive to other's pain, needs |
Is always there for friends, acquaintances, strangers, and even foes | Resists reciprocation of support, sacrifice |
Seeks reconciliation | Seeks revenge |
Seeks ways to provide help | Helpless: "I can't do it by myself!" |
Goes out of their way | Just "too busy" |
Performs well even under pressure | Tendency toward overwhelm |
If it's not yours, respect it | "Take it and run" |
Have learned the "secret" of contentment | "Make me feel good!" (food, money, attention, sex, religion, et al) |
Seeks constructive, positive means to achieve goals through genuine dialogue and constructive conflict | Starts fights and perpetuates unrest but longs for "peace" |
Always satisfied, but looking for new opportunities for growth | Never content, but unwilling to seek growth opportunities |
Future-Oriented | Past-And-Immediate-Present Oriented |
Words and promises have meanings | Words and promises can't be trusted |
Keeps promises | "Intends" to keep promises |
Direct | Indirect |
Cooperative | Demanding |
Sharing, Open | Controlling |
Calls for teamwork for benefit of others | Call for "Teamwork" only for their benefit |
Patient | Impatient |
Mature | Immature |
Sharing | Selfish |
Faith is a truly permeating heart-and-soul reality | "Faith" is a shallow external facade |
Approachable | Unapproachable |
Submits to God's will to be done | High/unrealistic expectations of others to do things the right (i.e. "their") way |
Love-driven | Fear-driven |
Release everything to God's plan | If you can't control it, kill it! |
What will be will be good | What will be will be (fatalistic) |
Gospel-Driven | Law-Driven |
Givers:
1) Givers provide and inject energy and enthusiasm.
2) Givers are positive thinkers with a vision for the future.
3) Givers have a capacity for risk, pain and enduring through the long haul.
4) Givers uphold, encourage and support others.
5) Givers trust leaders.
6) Givers are committed and accustomed to sacrifice, sometimes great sacrifice.
7) Givers are able to spot needs and fill them.
8) Givers require minimum support for maximum effectiveness.
9) Givers reciprocate trust and confidence.
10) Givers respect others and take relationships and people seriously.
A Warning To Givers Regarding Takers
No matter how much counseling, intervention, help, support and teamwork one offers to the "nice" taker, the taker will eventually and inevitably reject the giver once the givers gift is no longer wanted, needed, or deemed important.
The Vintage "Taker"
"Taker"'s can take all kinds of forms, but the common denominator is they are individuals who cry "unfair" or whine about being "victimized."
Not everyone gives or takes for the same reason. Instead, there are four basic combinations of "giver" and "taker" variables.
- #1 Givers Who Give: The most altruistic of the four possibilities, givers who give are generous to a fault. No matter what they do, they just can't be paid back. Their value system, their faith, and their inclination is such that whatever they have they just want to give as freely, frequently and sacrificially as they can. It is what gives them joy.
#2 Givers Who Take: These include those who give for selfish reasons. They give to get. Whenever they give, they have strings attached. At first, recipients of their gifts, services, etc. may be enthralled, surprised, shocked or bewildered. But it doesn't take too long to see that the giving had a price tag attached. Often this can be a hideous, hypocritical sham of generosity. Their joy is not in giving. It is in controlling through often well-executed "bribes."
#3 Takers Who Give: This kind of taker is direct, appreciative and accepting of gifts, appreciation, honors, recognition, power, etc. They feel deserving of gifts, wages, bonuses and benefits. They will even fight tooth and nail to preserve their rights to receive what they have rightfully earned. However, once the rewards are in their possession, they give freely as #1's with no strings attached.
#4 Takers Who Take: This simply describes one as self-centered as #2, but who really cares very little (if at all) about anyone else's welfare, needs, etc. Taking all they can get, they hoard possessions, wages, services, et al. Of course, the more that is hoarded, the better it can be hidden behind a facade of very nice homes, cars, dress, jewelry, and other impressive titles, etc.
Of course, the greater the degree to which one's final objective is to take or give, one can expect greater use of taking or giving behaviors. Taking behaviors will also be characterized by a greater use of power plays or other controlling behaviors including intimidation, interrogation, poor-me, and/or aloof-ness.
For more information see. Ministry Health article #153 "Forty-Two Power Plays" and #63 "Four Types of Manipulators").
Givers: The Most Obvious Proof
Are you a "giver" or "taker?" The familiar words of Paul to the Corinthians comes to mind.
"Each man should give what he has decided in his heart to give, not reluctantly or under compulsion [as a "taker" does], for God loves a cheerful giver."
(II Corinthians 9:7 NIV emphasis added)
No comments:
Post a Comment